Roots and Wings (Class 6)A Speech to Save Environment — Summary & Analysis

A Speech to Save Environment — Summary & Analysis — Notes

A Speech to Save Environment — Summary & Analysis

Speaker: Severn Cullis-Suzuki

Genre: Speech (Non-fiction prose)

Curriculum: Class 6 | Roots and Wings | English Literature

About the Speaker

Severn Cullis-Suzuki (born 1979) is a Canadian environmental activist who became famous worldwide when she delivered this speech at the age of twelve. She is the daughter of David Suzuki, a well-known Canadian scientist and environmentalist. Growing up in a family deeply concerned about nature and the environment, Severn developed a strong sense of responsibility towards the planet from a very young age.

She founded the Environmental Children's Organization (ECO) along with her friends when she was nine years old. The group was formed to educate other children about environmental issues and to show that even young people can work to make a difference. ECO raised money to attend the United Nations Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, in 1992.

Severn went on to study biology at Yale University and has continued her work as an environmental activist, author, and speaker throughout her life. She has written books on nature and sustainability and continues to speak at international forums about climate change and environmental protection.

This speech, delivered at the 1992 Earth Summit, made Severn known as "the girl who silenced the world for five minutes." It is included in the Class 6 Roots and Wings English Literature textbook because it teaches students about environmental responsibility and the power of speaking up for what you believe in.

Speech Walkthrough

Part 1: Introduction and Purpose

Severn begins by introducing herself and her group:

> "Hello, I am Severn Suzuki, speaking for ECO, the Environmental Children's Organization."

She tells the audience that she and her friends are between twelve and thirteen years old. Their group includes Morgan, Tove, Michelle, and Severn herself. They have come from far away for one reason: to tell the adults in the room that things must change.

> "You adults, you must change your ways."

She says she has no personal agenda. She has not come to sell anything or to win an election. She has come to fight for her future. She makes a sharp comparison: losing her future is not like losing an election or losing some points in the stock market. It is something far more serious and permanent.

Part 2: Speaking for All Life on Earth

Severn says she is speaking not just for herself, but for all generations to come. She is also speaking on behalf of the starving children around the world and on behalf of the dying animals that have no place left to go.

She describes her own fears:

  • She is afraid to go out in the sun because holes in the ozone layer make the sun's rays dangerous.
  • She is afraid to breathe the air because she does not know what chemicals are in it.
  • She used to go fishing near her home in Vancouver with her father, but a few years ago they found the fish were full of cancer.
  • She talks about the plants and animals disappearing every day, forever. She says she grew up dreaming of seeing wild animals, jungles, rainforests, birds, and butterflies. But now she wonders: will her own children ever get to see these things?

    She turns to the audience and asks: "Did you have to worry about these things when you were my age?"

    Part 3: The Problem with Adult Thinking

    Severn points out a dangerous way of thinking that adults have: they believe they have all the time in the world and all the solutions. But she argues this is false. The damage is happening right in front of everyone's eyes, yet people act as if it will all work out.

    She admits she does not have all the answers either. But she points out something important: if adults do not know how to fix the damage, they should at least stop causing it.

    > "If you don't know how to fix it, please stop breaking it."

    She lists things that adults cannot undo:

  • You cannot fix the holes in the ozone layer.
  • You cannot bring back salmon that have died.
  • You cannot bring back extinct animals.
  • You cannot turn a desert back into a forest.
  • If these things cannot be undone, why keep doing them?

    Part 4: One Human Family

    Severn addresses the people in the conference room directly. Some are government delegates, some are businesspeople, some are reporters or politicians. She reminds all of them that they are part of one family: five billion humans and thirty million species, all living together on one planet. No border or government can change that fact.

    She says she is just a child, but she knows that everyone is in this together and must act as one world, with one shared goal.

    She also says she is not afraid to express how she feels. When she is angry, she says it. When she is scared, she says it too. She is not ashamed of her emotions.

    Part 5: The Inequality of the World

    Severn then talks about the problem of inequality between rich and poor countries. In her country, Canada, she has a comfortable life: good food, clean water, a home, bicycles, computers, television sets. She says if she were to list everything she owns, it would take two days.

    But two days before giving the speech, she and her friends spent time with children living in the favelas (slums) of Rio de Janeiro. The contrast shocked her. One child asked a question that stayed with her: "Why is that one child so greedy?" The question was about children like Severn herself, who have so much while others have so little.

    This moment made Severn think: it is a matter of chance where you are born. She could have been one of the children in the favelas of Rio. She could have been a starving child in Somalia. She could have been a victim of war in the Middle East. She could have been a beggar in India. The only difference is where she happened to be born.

    She then makes a powerful point: if all the money spent on wars were redirected to solving environmental problems, ending poverty, and finding cures for disease, the Earth would become a much better place to live.

    Part 6: What Children Are Taught vs. What Adults Do

    Severn points to a contradiction that she cannot understand. In schools and kindergartens, children are taught:

  • Do not fight with others.
  • Work things out peacefully.
  • Respect others.
  • Keep things clean.
  • Do not hurt other creatures.
  • Share with others.
  • Do not be greedy.
  • These are the rules children live by. But then she asks: why do adults go out into the world and do exactly the opposite of what they tell children to do?

    > "Then why do you go out and do the things you tell us not to do?"

    Part 7: A Direct Challenge to the Adults

    In the final section of her speech, Severn speaks directly to the delegates and reminds them of why they are at the conference. She tells them not to forget who they are doing this for. The answer is simple: they are doing it for their own children.

    She says parents are supposed to comfort their children by telling them that everything will be all right, that this is not the end of the world, and that adults are doing their best. But she says adults can no longer make that promise because their actions do not support those words.

    She asks one sharp question: "Are we even on your list of priorities?"

    She closes by quoting her father: "You are what you do, not what you say." She says what adults are doing to the environment makes her cry at night. And she challenges every adult in the room:

    > "You grown-ups say you love us. But I challenge you: please make your actions reflect your words."

    Themes and Analysis

    1. Environmental Responsibility

    The central theme of the speech is the urgent need to protect the environment. Severn uses personal examples such as the cancer-filled fish in Vancouver, the holes in the ozone layer, and the disappearing rainforests to show that environmental destruction is not an abstract problem. It is happening right now, and it is affecting real people and real ecosystems. The speech teaches students that every person, not just scientists or politicians, has a responsibility towards the environment.

    2. The Voice of Children

    Severn represents children as a powerful moral force. She is twelve years old, has no political power, and no money. But she has clarity and honesty. The speech shows that children can speak truth to power and demand accountability from the adults who make decisions. The idea that a child's voice matters is central to the speech and is a lesson that resonates with Class 6 students.

    3. The Gap Between Words and Actions

    One of the most striking themes is the difference between what adults say and what they do. They claim to love their children. They teach children to share, to respect others, and not to be greedy. But their actions, through pollution, overconsumption, and war, contradict these values. Severn challenges this hypocrisy directly and asks adults to align their actions with their words.

    4. Global Inequality

    Severn draws attention to the vast difference in living standards between rich countries like Canada and poor communities like the favelas of Rio de Janeiro. She argues that wealth is a matter of where you are born, not of merit or hard work alone. This raises questions of fairness and justice. Rich nations consume far more than their share and do not share enough with those who are struggling. For Class 6 students, this is an important introduction to the concept of global inequality.

    5. One World, One Responsibility

    Severn argues that borders and governments cannot divide the human family. We are all one. The environmental crisis does not respect borders. Pollution in one country affects the air and water of another. Species extinction in one region affects ecosystems everywhere. She calls on everyone to act as a single world working towards a single goal.

    6. Intergenerational Justice

    A key idea in the speech is that the decisions made by today's adults will determine the world that future generations inherit. Severn speaks not just for herself but for all generations to come. She asks adults to take this responsibility seriously. This concept, that the present generation must protect resources and the environment for future generations, is at the heart of the idea of sustainable development.

    Literary Devices and Key Terminology

    Rhetorical Questions: Severn uses questions like "Did you have to worry about these things when you were my age?" and "Are we even on your list of priorities?" These are not meant to be answered. They are meant to make the audience think and feel the weight of their responsibility.

    Repetition: She repeats the phrase "I am only a child" several times throughout the speech. Each time she uses it, she is pointing out that even a child can see what adults refuse to acknowledge. The repetition adds emotional force.

    Personal Anecdote: Severn uses stories from her own life, such as fishing with her father in Vancouver and meeting children in Rio's favelas, to make her arguments personal and relatable. These are not statistics. They are human experiences.

    Direct Address: She speaks directly to the audience using "you," making each delegate feel personally responsible. This makes the speech feel like a conversation, not a lecture.

    Contrast and Comparison: She contrasts her life in Canada with the lives of children in the favelas. She contrasts what adults teach children with what adults actually do. These contrasts make her argument more powerful.

    Allusion: The speech alludes to real global issues such as the ozone layer, deforestation, species extinction, the salmon crisis in Vancouver, starvation in Somalia, and wars in the Middle East. These references ground the speech in real-world facts.

    Hypophora: She raises a question and then provides the answer herself. For example: "Who are you doing this for? We are your own children." This technique keeps the audience engaged and drives her argument forward.

    Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Severn uses all three modes of persuasion. Ethos: she establishes credibility by founding ECO and travelling to Rio. Pathos: she appeals to emotions through personal stories and fears. Logos: she makes logical arguments, such as the point that if money spent on war were redirected to environment and poverty, the world would be better.

    Important Quotes

    "Losing my future is not like losing an election or a few points in the stock market."

    Severn uses this comparison to show that environmental destruction is permanent and cannot be undone like a political or financial setback. The future of the planet cannot be recovered through another vote or another investment.

    "If you don't know how to fix it, please stop breaking it."

    This is the most famous line from the speech. It is simple, direct, and devastating. It challenges the logic of continuing harmful practices when no one knows how to reverse the damage.

    "I am only a child, yet I know we are all in this together and should act as one single world towards one single goal."

    This line shows that global thinking does not require age or power. Even a child can understand what world leaders sometimes forget.

    "You are what you do, not what you say."

    Quoted from her father, this line is the moral conclusion of the speech. It calls adults to account for the gap between their loving words and their destructive actions.

    "You grown-ups say you love us. But I challenge you: please make your actions reflect your words."

    The closing challenge. It is both a plea and a demand. It leaves the audience with a clear moral responsibility.

    Key Takeaways for Students

  • The speech was delivered by twelve-year-old Severn Cullis-Suzuki at the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro on behalf of her group ECO (Environmental Children's Organization).
  • Severn speaks for future generations, endangered animals, and children around the world who are affected by environmental destruction.
  • Key environmental problems mentioned: holes in the ozone layer, air pollution with unknown chemicals, fish dying of cancer, plants and animals going extinct, deforestation.
  • The central argument: "If you don't know how to fix it, please stop breaking it."
  • Severn highlights global inequality: children in Canada live with abundance while children in Somalia starve and children in Rio live in slums.
  • She points out the contradiction between what adults teach children (share, respect, do not be greedy) and what adults actually do in the world.
  • The speech ends with a challenge: make your actions match your words.
  • Important literary devices to remember: rhetorical questions, repetition of "I am only a child," personal anecdote, direct address, contrast, ethos/pathos/logos.
  • For exam purposes: know the full name of the speaker (Severn Cullis-Suzuki), the event (1992 Earth Summit, Rio de Janeiro), and the name of her organization (ECO).
  • The phrase "You are what you do, not what you say" comes from her father's teaching.
  • Watch the full video here: YouTube